Friday, May 13, 2016

TRUST and FAITH: On Breaching the Barrier



"How could you, a mathematician, a man devoted to reason and logical proof....how could you believe that extraterrestrials are sending you messages? How could you believe that you are being recruited by aliens from outer space to save this world? How could you......?
.........................
 " Because" Nash  said slowly in his soft  reasonable, southern  drawl as if talking to himself, "the ideas I had about supernatural beings came to me the same way that mathematical ideas did. So I took them seriously." 

That was  from A Beautiful Mind : a biography of the  Nobel laureate and mathematical genius John Forbes Nash Jr. by Sylvia Nasar.


Almost half a century earlier Srinivasan Ramanujan had put it  slightly differently  "An equation for me has no meaning unless it expresses a thought of God". He was  certain that   it was goddess Namagiri, to whom he owed his mathematical gifts. Namagiri would write the equations on his tongue, Namagiri  would bestow mathematical insights in his dreams.  (The Man who knew Infinity  a   biography of Srinivasan Ramanujan by  Robert Kanigel 



Their respective colleagues   would state categorically that it was as if  Ramanujan and Nash knew the final answers before they even saw the problem. How do such brilliant  minds work?  Is it intuition?  The Oxford dictionary defines intuition as immediate apprehension or insight  without reasoning. 

Scientists are forever  curious to know.  Google's   AlphaGO , an  algorithm   programmed to play the board game GO, is the latest attempt to mimic this elusive human trait.   Located on networked computers (technical term distributed computing) the AlphaGO algorithm enables  
A GO game in progress(courtesy en:wikipedia)
Played with white and black chips, it is basically  a "surround and eliminate"  game
not only programmed moves but also  intuitive decisions, its creators claim.  With a
 computing power amounting to 1202 CPUs and 172 GPUs,   AlphaGO  demonstrated its capability  when it won 4-1  against the world champion Lee Sedol, recently.  

Tailpiece:
"Proof and Verification"  are the mainstays of Science.  In a recent editorial Nature cautions: Intuitive machines will need more than trust; they will demand Faith. 

A Beautiful Mind, biography of the Nobel laureate John Forbes Nash Jr. by  Sylvia Nasar  was made into a film in 2001 with the same title.    "The Man who knew Infinity"  a film based on Kanigel's book  has just been released. 

References:
1. The man who knew Infinity : Robert Kanigel,  Scriber 1991;Abacus 1999
2. A Beautiful Mind : Sylvia Nasar, Faber& Faber 1998
3. A Mathematician's Apology : G.H. Hardy , Cambridge University Press, 1967
4. AlphaGO 
4. How Google's AlphaGO Beat Lee Sedol
5. In two moves AlphaGO and Lee Sedol Redefined the future
5. Digital Intuition Nature, 529, 437 (28 January 2016)