Friday, April 11, 2025

Babes in the Digital Woods

 "Lucid, Memorable, Galvanizing". That is how The Wallstreet Journal  described  the   book : The  Anxious Mind- How  the great  rewiring of the  childhood is causing  an epidemic  of mental illness.  This book  has been on the  2024 Best seller list  for several weeks and has been discussed at length  by parents and experts.  The author Jonathan Haidt  is a  professor at New York  University  Stern School  of Business  who  specializes  in  social psychology.

Haidt  laments  that with the advent  of smartphones,  today's adolescents ( 10-20 age group)  are lost in the  dark labyrinths of the digital world.   They  are drawn irretrievably  to the  friends and friendships of the virtual world rather  than the solid  realities  of the physical  world.  True,  adults are equally   addicted  to and influenced  by  the  social media platforms. But,  Haidt  argues adolescents are  more at risk, more vulnerable  to the charms extruded by the  virtual  world.  They could be permanently scarred, leading to the possibility of mental illnesses.  Haidt suggestions  for  "a healthier  childhood in  a digital world" include No smart phones before   high school, no social media before16  and  phonefree  schools"  

Why adolescents are at risk?  Though thankfully brief, adolescence, an essential  phase of growing up, is indeed a  very difficult time for both boys and girls.    Hormonal influx  initiates hitherto unexperienced  and novel changes   in the body and the child within  struggles to come to terms  with awareness of  sexuality.  Anxiety, curiosity, apprehension, doubts and above all questions abound.  Overwhelming  majority of the  teenagers tide over  this  turbulent phase naturally  without any serious repercussion. However  there are exceptions. As  Silvers point out  " for some youth  adolescence marks the beginning or worsening of psychopathology characterized by difficulties with emotion regulation."   

During the transition  phase  more than parents/teachers/siblings, it is the peer group that becomes  trusted confidante.  To be accepted by them, to be like them, to be one of them  means a lot.  But  tragedy  is,  instead of  dealing directly with  real friends, in the real world, in real time,  today's adolescents opt for  the social media platforms to interact.    Where everything is easy and just a click away. To some extent parents are responsible for this trend, Haidt  argues.  Distrustful of neighbors and neighborhoods , paranoid  parents feel their wards are safer in the digital world. 

In a recent interview with  BBC,  Haidt  warned that  utter disaster is all set to descend on us in the form of   AI, the all powerful Artificial Intelligence.   As the boundaries between True and Fake tend  to blur ,  societal  set up  as we  know now may cease to exist. 

Or  who knows,  perhaps AI disaster might turn out to be a blessing in disguise. When nothing can be trusted in the virtual world,   innate human  intelligence  will  win.   Teenager might   shrug off the digital world  as easily and  naturally as a child discards  cartoons  as it grows.   


References

Haidt,J 
Penguin, New York, NY, 2024, ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-0241694909

Haidt to BBC

Pearson 
Nature  2025 vol.640,pp26-28

Odjers  
Nature 2024  vol. 628, pp.29-30.

Sawyer,  et al.
Lancet Child Adolesc Health. 2018; 2:223-228

Somerville, L. H. (2013) 
Current directions in psychological science, 22(2), 121-127.

Orben, A ∙ Blakemore, SJ
Nature. 2023; 614:410-412

Silvers, JA
Curr Opin Psychol. 2022; 44:258-263

Sahi et al 
Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience 2023,August Volume 62, 101262