@ Vienna :TWAS 2015

Austrian Academy of Sciences

Frescoes inside the seminar hall

The  26th Annual general meeting of The World Academy of Sciences (TWAS) was held at Vienna this November. Austrian Academy of Sciences hosted the meeting and naturally the venue was the Academy itself.  This imposing historic building built in 1755 and  inaugurated by Maria Theresa originally housed the University of Vienna. During the 1848 revolution, the building catered to military needs accommodating soldiers. It was in 1857 that the Kaiserliche Academie der Wissenschaften ( Imperial Academy of Sciences) moved in here.  In 1947 its name was changed to Austrian Academy of Sciences.  The frescoes inside the building are   beautiful. The  side panels represent four traditional branches of knowledge of the University: Theology, jurisprudence,philosophy and medicine. These were painted by Gregorio Guglielmi. 

This year's theme for the conference was Sustainable Development and how science and scientists can enable and accelerate these process. Delivering the  keynote lecture, Albert Louis Sachs however cautioned that sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) must necessarily  include the needs of the poor.  Sachs had served as one of the six judges in the Constitutional Court of South Africa for fifteen years from 1994-2009. He highlighted the case of Grootboom V Constitutional court of South Africa.  Adequate housing is guaranteed in the constitution of South Africa and the SA Government identified several plots of lands to build low cost housing. However due to a combination of circumstances helpless people such as Grootboom and several others had to pitch huts in one of these plots.  SA Government evicted them, without providing any alternative.  Grootboom went to the court.  The case came up before Albert Sachs. He judgement  was in favor of Grootboom, however it is another story that Irene Grootboom died in a shanty at the age of 39.


A roof and at least one square meal- demands of the poor are so minimal. But  that  doesn't mean they  can be sidelined or totally excluded  when the rest of the world makes plans for a better  future.  This brings into sharp focus contemporary concerns in several developing  countries. In the name of development agricultural lands are being erased and forest areas are encroached into. Balanced and all inclusive equations alone would lead to sustainable development. 

Tailpiece
 At one stage Vienna was the power center of Europe and empress Maria Theresa decided the fate of the continent. Palaces,and churches ...  the city has so many attractions .Vienna was also the musical capital and  we indulged   ourselves in  a concert at the Mozarthauz. Mozarthauz is the oldest concert hall in Vienna where Mozart used to entertain  Bishop Colloredo.  And then, of course Vienna is also the city of Freud. His house is a museum now.    

At the Freud Museum 

 Inside the Mozarthauz

''Pot''ful of medicines

For decades  intoxicating heavy smoke has  hid the medical benefits of the pot . Because of this,  Governments   outlawed the poor plant Cannabis Sativa together with its cousins  indica and ruderalis, root, stalk and leaves. But  how long can you suppress scientific curiosity?    Now scientists want to relook at the plant and the chemicals it produces, because they believe cannabinoids( a general term for chemicals derived from the plant) could lead to very useful  pharmaceutical products.  Governmental regulations in some countries have loosened their grip to allow enough flexibility for scientific research. 

It is assumed that Cannabis plant originated  in central Asia  and spread across the globe. Humans made use of the plant mainly for the grain and  fiber  (hemp). Somewhere around 2700 BC , Chinese emperor Shen Nung  discovered the medicinal potential  of the plant. Its leaves or buds were burnt and smoke inhaled to relieve pain. Millenniums later,while working at the Medical College of Calcutta, India,  W.B O'Shaughnessy an  Irish doctor,  discovered the use of Cannabis among the natives both as a medicine  as well as recreational drug.  In October 1839 , he presented a paper  On the preparations of the Indian Hemp (orGunjah) .  Portuguese physician  Garcia de Orta,  spent  better part of his life in India researching tropical medicines. In his book Colloquies on the simples and drugs of India gives a detailed account of  Bangue, Cannabis indica.    But these were  not exactly systematic scientific studies and hence the medical benefits  of Cannabis remained unsubstantiated.  That is the flashback for Marijuana the grass and its  crudely refined products hashish/charas.

 On the leaves and buds  the plant  bears  little pimple like protrusions called trichomes and these are rich in a variety of chemicals classified as   cannabinoids, terpenes etc.  The poor plant produces these chemicals for a variety of reasons  for example to  to lessen moisture loss, to ward off predators and to shield off ultraviolet rays. Reading O'Shaughnessy's paper British  chemists were excited and they isolated   Cannabinol from the plant extract   in 1899.     

 Cannabis flowers with Trichome
Courtesy Wikipedia 

Cannabinol: Courtsey:Wikipedia

Chemists  were  just rolling up their sleeves to dig  deeper into the  plant concoctions to isolate more active ingredients, but alas  International Regulations and  Laws banned the    handling and use of psychotropic substances. Special pemissions had to be obtained to work on all narcotics. But  there  are those  who are not easily deterred.  And hence a few groups toiled on. Israeli chemist Mechoulam isolated the one and only  psychotropic ingredient in Cannabis,  Tetra Hydro Cannabinol (THC). It was indeed a huge morale boost for them when follow up studies by  neuro pharmacologists  showed  that  humans have built in receptors CB1 and CB2 specially reserved for Cannabinoids. That meant two things:   the human  body is  equipped  to receive cannabinoidlike chemicals and might actually be producing some ! Of these receptors  CB1 type is  found mostly in the central nervous system and CB2 in the immune system.   In  2014, a review appeared in the journal of American Academy of Neurology on the Efficacy and safety  of medical marijuana in selected neurologial disorders. . 

Cannabidiol(CBD) Courtesy: wikipedia

Tetra Hydro cannabinol(THC)
Courtesy: wikipedia

GW pharmaceuticals based in UK  holds permission for conducting research in cannabinoids. A mouthspray developed from whole cannabis extract is approved in several countries for treatment of spasticity in multiple sclerosis patients. Another  drug  for epilepsy will soon be in market.  

Reference 

1. Cannabis Outlook: Nature 24 September 2015. 

Desert Tales

Africa : NASA picture 

In the scorching sands of Saharan desert why doesn't the Cataglyphis bombycina get roasted like a peanut? These tiny creatures  go by the common name Saharan silver ants. As the name suggests these ants  are native to  the  hot Saharan desert and have a silvery glaze. Saharan desert, stretching across northern Africa,  skirted  by the Atlantic ocean on the west, the Red sea on the East and the Mediterranean sea on the north  is not at all a friendly terrain to pitch a hut.  Here ambient   temperature can soar to 54 degree Celsius and sand temperature could be as high as 80 deg.C. Most of the desert creatures are crepuscular, that is they come out either during dawn or dusk. But alas   poor silver ants can't afford to forage during  twilight hours  because of predators. So to avoid being caught and made into a meal these  ants forage when the predators are having  their siesta; that is  at noon, when the Sun is at the peak. Professor Rüdiger   Wehner and his team at the University of Zurich have been fascinated by these ants for quite some time.   They   have been looking into the   the neurophysiology and behavioral pattern of these ants with special emphasis on vision as  a strong cognitive capability. In the 17th July issue of Science magazine  Professor Wehner and his team provide  answers to the critical question : How do these tiny insects keep their cool ?   They could very well  have asked why are these ants so shiny.

Community dinner: courtesy wikipedia

  

There are  several interesting things about C. bombycina.   Their   unusually   long legs  lift the body 4-5 mm above the ground. Such high ground clearance means, the ellipsoidal body, not more than a cm in size is considerably cooler than the scorching sand below. Long legs also mean speed. These ants  can run  fast and far off in search of food. This has been captured in a excellent video. If it goes far off, how does it get back to its burrough? It seems smell and sights of the starting point stored in their brain  guide it safely back to home ground.

But how does it ward off the heat? Prof. Wehner and   his team provide the answers in their paper. The silvery sheen is not just a beauty enhancer. It is indeed a very effective thermoregulation feature. The shine  is due to a thick mop of fine silvery hair covering the dorsal and lateral sides of the body. The morphology of the hair has been studied by electron microscopy .  triangular cross section and taper off to the tip. These hairs perform  multiple tasks, strictly in accordance with the Laws of Physics. The triangular surfaces facilitate   total internal reflection and thus enhance reflectivity in the visible and near infra-red regions of the solar spectrum and      in the mid infrared region the hair layer demonstrates  very high emissivity. In other words exactly opposite of what  solar panels do. For excellent performance a typical solar heating panel must have zero reflectivity ( very high absorprtivity) at low wavelengths to capture maximum heat  and very low emissivity at high wavelengths to minimize radiation heat loss.

Desert creatures have evolved  several  adaptive strategies to encounter the twin threats of high heat and lack of water.  For example certain types of desert  rodents  generate water as a metabolic by-product.  At the cellular level, heat shock proteins  see to it that   heat and dryness don't impair the structure and hence the function of biological molecules.  

References:

1.  Keeping cool: Enhanced optical reflection and radiative heat dissipation in Saharan silver ants. Nan Shi et al Science 17 July 2015 vo. 349 pp 298-301

2. Smells like home: Desert ants cataglyphis fortis use olefactory landmarks to pinpoint the nests 
3. The amazing Cataglyphis ant
4. Passive radiative cooling below ambient air temperature  under direct sunlight: Raman et al  Nature 515.pp540-44(2014)
5.Heat Shock protein synthesis and thermotolerance in cataglyphis, an ant from Saharan desert -Gehring and Wehner : PNAS 92, 2994- 2998 (19995)

On Information : Transmission & Storage.

What happens if the information superhighway- (or infobahn if you prefer) gets clogged? Choc-a-block like any other highway? The rate at which new users hop on to internet, this indeed is a possibility, though the danger is not imminent.   Traffic in the information superhighway  has been increasing   by 60% annually for the last 15 years. Though we haven't yet reached danger level, still it is imperative that we take note of the situation and have solutions in place.  

Courtsy: wikipedia

Silica, the material used for optical fiber,  has exceptional properties. Extremely low signal loss (attenuation coefficient ~4.6x10^-5m^-1) and an equally small nonlinear refractive index -(n₂₌2.5x10^-20m²W^-1 ). So light undergoes total internal reflection inside the hollow fiber wth the walls just containing and steering its its path. But overcrowding can change all that. Nonlinear error (also called Kerr effect) could add up over volume and distance and distort signals. Another term used for such distortion is crosstalk.  A  fiber material with  n₂=0, will be the ideal solution.  In that case there will be no interference and no cross-talk whatsoever. 

Professor Radic and his team at the University of California, San Diego thought differently. What if we can cancel these nonlinear responses?  To achieve this Radic and team designed  "frequency combs" which synchronized the frequency variations in the optical data flow and  demonstrated that carrier coherence is the critical requirement to eliminate crosstalk. Because under such circumstances cross-talk is predictable and reversible.  Their results are published in the 26th June issue of Science. This study implies possibilities beyond the current limits of the reach and volume in optical fiber communication. 

Transmission is one thing; what about storage? Just to cite an example: Human Genome Project and  International Cancer Genome Consortium (ICGC) would have by generated data running into  petabytes.(One petabyte =10¹⁵ bytes ). Cloud Services (which includes storage and computing facilities) is one platform where such enormous volume of data could reside. This would provide easy and fast access and usage to multiple research teams across the globe. Of course there is price tag attached. Currently alongside titans such as Amazon, Google and Microsoft, there are smaller firms too offering this service.  It is reliably learned that National Institutes of Health, USA  will soon move some of its information wealth  to a cloud storage facility. Europe is perhaps is planning its own version. 

But some remain skeptical, what if your cloud bank  bursts?.  

Reference:
1.Overcoming Kerr-induced capacity limit in optical fiber transmission. Temprana et al Science: 26 June 2015 pp1445-48. 
2.Cloud Cover: Nature 9 July 2015 pp 128
3.Create a cloud Commons:Stein et al  Nature 9 July 2015 pp 149-151.
4.Europe sets its sights on Cloud: Gibney,E-Nature 9 July 2015 pp136-37 
5 Cloud's worst case scenario- What to do if your provider goes belly up

Man to Machine: "Think,Decide, Act!."

The kind of acrobatics that robots are called upon to perform  in science fiction novels/ movies , would certainly cost them an arm or a leg. However in SF Imagination is unbound and  the limbs regrow  in a jiffy.  But alas!  Imagination and Reality are not so close neighbors.   Currently  a reality  check is being done on   the possible options available for a robot injured  in  action, in the battle field. Their focus is to  design robots that can adapt like animals. (1,2). Living beings possess natural instincts accumulated over time, and also revised/ refined through learning and memory, to adapt to unexpected and uncertain situations. Cully et al  equipped the robot with   a  unique trial and error algorithm (a behaviour-performance map with weighted values)   The algorithm contained   a number of possible failure modes and their corresponding most optimal responses. So to begin with Cully et al envisaged   a robot injured  in about 19 different ways, with  broken arm or a leg.   Empowered with  this  behavior-performance map,  the robot could manage the situation in less than 2 minutes.  The leader of the team Jean-Baptistre Mouret says "I study machine learning and evolutionary computation to design highly adaptive robots". Mouret's website presents  several, very  interesting videos  that explains it all.  

Courtesy: wikipedia

Just about a year ago   we were amazed how a paraplegic equipped with an exoskeleton propped by an array of electronic devices, proved a point  (World Cup 2014: The symbolic first kick).  A year later Aflalo and team show that an intention  can actually be translated  into an action(3,4). The volunteer,   EGS,   is paralyzed from neck down for the past ten years, but   nerve cells in his  posterior parietal cortex is still active. Posterior parietal cortex is the main area where prework for an action, happens,  in other words  intentionality. Aflalo etal detected that EGS's thought processes selectively fire  nerve cells in this area. The team  took a cue from this and began a process of reading his thoughts. Each time they could check with him whether they read correctly; that was an added advantage. The research team tapped the signals via tiny silicon chips embedded in the brain and then fed into a robotic arm or a computer screen to move the cursor.These silicone chips, an array of 96 microscopic electrodes have been approved by the USFDA (United States Food and Drug Administration ) for commercialization.  A  definite step forward in the development of  next generation neuro-prosthetic devices.  Videos are available at Professor Richard Andersen's webpage. 

References:
1. Robots that can adapt like animals : Cully etal Nature 28 May 2015 pp503-507 
2.Robots with instincts : Adami: Nature 28 May 2015 pp 426-427
3.Decoding motor imagery from the posterior parietal cortex of a tetraplegic human :Aflalo etal Science 22 May 2015, pp906-910 
4. Reading the mind to move the body: Pruszynski & Diedriehsen Science 22 May 2015 pp 860-861

Hubble Telescope : 25 years in the sky

It is indeed party time.   You have an open invite to  join the celebrations. For a quarter of a century,since its launch on 24th April 1990, Hubble space telescope has been functioning as our  eyes  in the sky  with a unique mission. Tracing galactic histories, witnessing  cosmic events, unraveling the mysteries of black holes, dark matter, dark energy.....

There were initial hiccups.  Though Hubble began transmitting pictures within a couple of months, they were of poor quality .   It took three and a half years to fix a defective  reflector. In January 1994, earth station received the first clear pictures from Hubble. Then on 2nd November 1995, Hubble transmitted its first masterpiece the Pillars of Creation, a composite of 32 frames  from 4 individual cameras. An unbelievably beautiful and enigmatic   insight into  the formation of a star. How  a nascent star draws  raw material from these gaseous columns  of hydrogen gas and cosmic dust.   Hubble has been  relaying information about  the universe; information  hitherto unknown and unsuspected

Pillars of creation :Eagle Nebula M16
Credit: NASA, ESA, and the Hubble Heritage Team (STScI/AURA)

In 1999  when the comet Shoemaker-Levy 9 crashed into planet Jupiter,  Hubble  enjoyed a ringside seat. It stood  witness to an amazing  cosmic accident.  Jupiter's  enormous gravitational pull   disintegrated the comet  into several pieces and as they fell,  violent shock waves were generated. Equally fascinating  was the visual proof of dark matter in a set of galaxy cluster collision images captured by Hubble and Chandra, the X-ray observatory. While Chandra glued its eyes on the hot gas emissions, Hubble observed the uncanny ability of  invisible dark matter to warp space and  thus deforming the images of heavenly bodies in the background

. 

six galaxy cluster collisions with dark matter maps.
 Courtsey: HubbleSite

 ''

Hubble  is  being periodically serviced  and could now be  well like the ship of Theseus, with most of its parts repaired or replaced. But its time is up.  Hubble  will be retired  from active service by 2020. Its successor, the  next generation James Webb Space Telescope(JWST) will be launched by 2018.  JWST,will carry a telescope roughly the size of a tennis-court with sharper    infra-red vision.  It is described as an observatory that folds up inside a rocket for launch and unfurls like a butterfly opening its wings upon nearing its orbit. 

Edwin Powell Hubble was a world renowned Astronomer. But   Who is James Webb ?  Jim Webb is neither a scientist nor an engineer. He was an efficient administrator.  Second person to head  the nascent yet mighty NASA, he  could hold his own in  the power corridors of Washington D.C and deftly negotiate the bureaucratic labyrinths,  Jim Webb set the space program of NASA on a solid footing.   

Dusty spiral galaxy ngc4414Image Credit: The Hubble Heritage Team (AURA/STScI/NASA)

Catching up with Nature - Breathlessly!

Pitcher plant (courtesy :Wikipedia)

SLIPS Technologies Inc.  a company anchored at Cambridge , Massachusetts, is barely a year old. Unusually slippery surface of the pitcher  plant inspired a group of researchers and that is the genesis of this company.  SLIPS is the acronym for Slippery Liquid Infused Porous Surface. The concept of a slippery surface which repels everything and anything was proven and reported   in a  research paper published  Nature in 2011. And in fact we covered it here.  Now  SLIPS Technologies Inc  is all set to market their products. To quote from their website- omniphobic surface  with optical transparence, scratch resistance, self-repair and self-cleaning characteristics that can operate under extreme environmental conditions.  

So what is the chemistry? Teflon and teflon coated non-stick vessels are household word now.  SLIPS uses similar materials from the vast family of  perfluorohydrocarbons for surface modification.  For example for medical devices undergo a two step surface coating process.  First a mono layer of teflon  is chemically grafted onto the device surface, which is then impregnated with a layer of another liquid perfluorocarbon. Such treated surfaces are called TLP  surfaces. (Tethered -Liquid Perflurocarbon surface). The super slippery surface of TLP treated medical devices  doesn't encourage blood clotting because neither fibrin nor platelets can adhere to the surface. For the same reason nor can bacteria form biofilm.(1,2)
  

Lotus leaf in water -Courtesy: Wikipedia

Scientists also marvel at the water repellence (super hydrophobicity) and self cleaning properties of the lotus leaf.  Water droplets get tossed around on the leaf surface and often aggregate to form bigger droplets and with the slightest tilt  falls off the leaf. But while  being tossed around,  the droplet would have smeared  all the dirt on itself and thus gently wiped the surface clean. Studies have  revealed that wax coated micro/nano "pimples" on the leaf surface drive  this unique phenomena.  Lotus effect has been recreated and replicated  on nano patterned surfaces. 

Now  Lu et al have  added  another innovative dimension to this effort. Their research paper appeared in the 6th March issue of Science(3). Super hydrophobic surfaces so far developed are mechanically  fragile and their performance graph dip when contaminated with  oil.  Liu and team have come up with an elegant  solution in the form of a paint formulation. Titanium dioxide nano particles coated with perfluorooctyltriethoxysilane is dispersed in ethanol.  Any surface, big or small can be coated  with this paint. Multiple coating techniques can be adopted: spraying, dip-coating, spin coating, extrusion- you name it.  The assorted titanium nanoparticles in the paint film take on the role of the "surface pimples". For the paint film to  stick strongly to the surface, a suitable  adhesive can be added to the formulation.  The robustness of the film  even after repeated exposure rough weather such "40 abrasion cycles with  sand paper " has been demonstrated on surfaces of  glass, cotton wool, steel, and filter paper. 

On one count the lotus leaf and pitcher plant still score high : Breathability.  Hold your breath- we will soon be getting there.  

References: 

1. Bioinspired coating for medical devices repel blood and bacteria
2. Literally nothing will stick to this new slippery surface
3. Robust self-cleaning surfaces that function when exposed to either air or oil: Lu eta al  
Science Vol. 347, issue 6226, pp 1132-5, 2015. 

Luck Factor in Cancer !!!

Everything in the Universe is a fruit of chance and necessity.

Democritus,  in ancient Greece,  around 400 BC.

Not just philosophers, but scientists too have subscribed to this concept. Molecular biologist Jacques Monod  (Nobel laureate in Medicine and Biology 1965)  explained the significance and relevance of chance and necessity  in biology in his  book bearing the same title. It looks like even cancer could be a matter of chance. So far  two factors have been implicated in cancer: genetic predisposition and/or environmental factors. "Environmental factors" a huge black box, would contain  anything that is not genetic. For example  smoking, pollutants, pesticide, radiation, junk food, unhealthy life style.......runs into a long list.  In a recent issue of Science  Tomasetti and Vogelstein   suggest  that   there is a third factor- an element of chance (1). Based on a statistical analysis of available data, they state  that ".......only a third of the variation in cancer risk among tissues is attributable to environmental factors or inherited predispositions; vast majority of the rest, is due to "bad luck".  And they trace this   luck factor  to  the  random (stochastic- if you prefer a more scholarly term ) mutations during the normal process of DNA replication  in  healthy,  non cancerous stem cells. 

Little unsettling indeed. But  they present  supporting data.  It is known that   certain tissues are more prone to cancer than others. For example lung cancer is more common than pelvic bone cancer. Incidence of brain tumor in spite of the  protective  blood-brain barrier, is much higher  than that of the small intestine where epithelial cells constantly encounter more toxic chemistry. Within the food processing zone itself, large intestine is at much higher risk than either  stomach or small intestine.  Why this variation?   Are there missing factors?  That is the question Tomasetti, a mathematician and Vogelstein, a cancer geneticist, both at different institutions under the umbrella of Johns Hopkins Medical School, asked. 

They decided to focus on the stem cells in  selected  tissues. Stem cells have the power to self replicate and are responsible for the architectural  integrity of a given tissue. Recent studies have unraveled a lot of information about them.  As stem cells self replicate, random mutations which are not necessarily carcinogen induced can occur.  By simple reasoning, as frequency of cell divisions shoots up, so will  the probability of stochastic mutations. Mutations could be innocuous by themselves. But could  they spell danger  collectively? Could they  function as a defect/error that   leads to cancer?  Two parameters needed to be estimated for the statistical modeling of such a  situation. : (i)  the lifetime risk of   various tissues developing cancer and (ii)  lifetime number of stem cell divisions  in a given tissue. Tomasetti and Vogelstein selected 31 tissue types for which these two parameters were available. A correlation plot substantiated their hypothesis. Colorectal tissue which registered about  trillion stem cell divisions, had a high lifetime risk almost close to 1, while pelvis osteosarcoma  with just over a million stem cell divisions ranked low. 

Many researchers were quick to protest.(2). Main objection was to the statement "we show that these stochastic influences are in fact major contributors to cancer overall, often more important than either hereditary or external environmental factors". Was the process of collecting and  interpreting the data  statistically sound? Was the data skewed? Was the sample size and spread  sufficient? Genuine doubts. But more than anything I guess the scientific community is angered by the terminology "Bad Luck". 

During  a recent  interview the duo likened their conclusions to the   probability of a motor vehicle accident. Consider your body  to be a car;   the  make and model of the car define your genetic makeup.    Road, weather  conditions etc.  reflect  the environmental factors.  Even if your car is in top condition, and the weather perfect,  you can't  totally eliminate the probability of an accident. (In this  scenario there is no place for the "other" erratic  driver). You can only be careful to a limit,  beyond that it is chance.  

The message I got was this-  go for  regular  check up; early detection could minimize the risk factor.   

Tailpiece: Bad luck indeed!
The plan was to view moonlit  Taj Mahal ; but   unseasonal downpour intervened. Two views from our hotel balcony.

At dusk 

In daylight  

The usual 

References 

1. Variation in Cancer risk among tissues can be explained by the number of stem cell divisions.  C. Tomasetti and B. Vogekstein, Science 2 January 2015, vol. 347, issue 6217 pages 78-83. 

2. Letters : On Cancer risk :  Science 13 Feb. 2015 Vo;l. 347, issue 6223, pages 727-730

Privacy in Public Space ?

In his novel  Dans le cafe de la  jeunesse perdue   Patrick Modiano (Nobel Prize for literature 2014 ) sketches Louki .  Never wanting to attract attention, at Cafe Conde', she always  stayed in the background or hid herself among the crowd. But alas!  in the rare and random group photos taken in cafe,  she stands out because of her photogenic face. When she goes missing , Mr Caislly a detective  is put on the job to trace her.   At one point  Mr Caisley   feels morally bound to respect  Louki's right to remain untraced.  The story is set in the 1960's, when it was easy to remain hidden from public view. Fast forward to modern times. Do we have the privilege to remain anonymous? Can we wish to be among the "Forgotten People"? Well,   I may be  a total stranger to my next door neighbor but I leave digital footprints all over.   Mobile phone, credit cards, browsing habits. everything leaves a mark. Oh! No not just marks, I generate   a pattern of  my behavioral traits- restaurants I frequent, favorite holiday spots,   reading/browsing  habits, favorite cab service.......So much so that  often I receive  helpful prompts : here is a book you may like or We haven't seen you for so long........ Such personalized messages are just one part, I might have inadvertently checked a tiny box somewhere sometime to "be in the loop".  

But what about anonymized or ghost data? We are talking about  millions of such  digital footprints  devoid of users' identification marks.  Because of ease of data collection, consolidation, filtration and processing  such ghost data( or metadata) , constitute rich gold mine  for market research, R&D activities  and  also for meaningful studies in sociology behavioral science, public health, etc.  How harmless are such  ghost datasets ? Not quite that is what Anthony Tocker found out.  Curious brains can mix/ match/superimpose ghost data with other pieces of  information freely available in the public domain  and breathe life into skeletons.  For example when New York City Taxi and Limousine Commission put out rather innocuous details  of millions of trips  for the year 2013 on the web, (of course without   passenger details)  it was not at all difficult for Anthony Tockar   to couple trip info with freely available public domain data  and   thus de-anonymize the riders. As simple as  putting 2 and 2 together, but in a rather complex way.  

de Montjoye, at the   computational privacy  at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, prefers to describe the process  as  Correlation Attack.  de Montjoye and his team decided to analyze credit card data in the same way. They collected  ghost data for credit card transactions over  a span of 3 months for  1.1 million people  and 10,000 shops  sans user name, sans  card number , sans shop name  and sans  time of transaction.    Armed with just the  details of   amount spent, shop type,  date stamp. and a code for each person, the team demonstrated that " 4 spatiotemporal  points are enough to uniquely reidentify  90% of individuals."  and  that " women are more identifiable than men in the credit card meta data." 

Efforts are on to fix such loopholes. Anonymous search engine duckduckgo doesn't capture user's ip address or store search history.  TrackMeNot  an add-on to Firefox or Chrome throws the tracker off the track and  into a Daedalian  labyrinth   with no Ariadne around to help. Researchers at Duke University have developed CacheCloak,  a program  which   camouflages mobile location.  Are we getting paranoid about our privacy?  Not necessarily. In my mobile contact list there are very few without a face; some have  uploaded their entire family! More interestingly there are monthly if not weekly updates.  Facebook too  tells the same  story; people are eager to talk about themselves, share their experiences- holidays, parties, workplace, constant updates...... Taking advantage of the millions of authenticated photos in their treasury, Facebook is all set to roll out DeepFace, a face recognition program, which can automatically tag a face with 97.25% accuracy. 

Perhaps  Digital Age has precipitated our eternal paradox: to  be unique and yet ordinary. 

Tailpiece:  

Stars, hide your fires;

Let not light see my black and deep desires                                                                           (Macbeth Act 1, Scene 4)

References:

.. 

1. Dans le Cafe de la jeunesse perdue : Patrick Modiano,  Gallimard 2007
2.Differential Privacy : The basics
3.Riding with the stars passenger privacy in the nyc taxicab dataset

4. Unique in Shopping mall : On the reidentifiability of credit card meta data 

de Montjoye et al Science 30 Jan. 2015, Vol. 347, issue 6221, pages 536-539
5. Hiding in plain sight, & Camouflaging searches in a sea of fake queries.
    Jia You  ibid page 500 & 502
6. Facebook will soon be able to ID you in any photo
6. Deep Face:Closing the gap to human level performance in face verification 

  

Inclusive Wealth Report 2012 & 2014.

Agricultural land, forest covers , high ranges and beaches are being lost to urbanization and development. This has a serious and direct  impact on the global ecological balance. For example a recent study states   that there is an increase in the atmospheric lightening over northern America due to global warming. Alarming indeed  because lightening triggers forest fires. The great barrier reef  that skirts the north eastern Australian coast  has been reduced by 50% over  the  last three decades.Among others coastal development and climate change are cited as reasons. Ocean warming has robbed coral off its color.  The great Himalayas,   prehistoric  Western Ghats, Amazonian forests and    mighty rivers are also facing threats.  Ecologists world over  believe we stand to lose much of our  natural heritage in our lifetime, if we don't take precautionary steps right away. While this may be a bit exaggerated, it is true that our natural wealth is being depleted.   We need to assess the instrumental value of our natural assets and then incorporate this  in the annual balance sheet- Just as the movable and immovable assets along with their depreciation show up in a company's  balance sheet. 

And therein lies the challenge. How do we compute  a nation's   wealth? In 2012 United Nations and World bank  brought together several like-minded agencies (UN University –International Human Dimensions Programme (UNU-IHDP) and the UN Environment Programme (UNEP), in collaboration with the UNESCOMahatma Gandhi Institute of Education for Peace and Sustainable Development (UNESCO-MGIEP), ASCENT Africa Sustainability Centre, the Malaysian Industry-Government Group for High Technology (MIGHT), Science to Action (S2A), the Ministry of Environment – Government of Japan, the UN University – Institute for the Advanced Study of Sustainability (UNU-IAS), and endorsed by the Science and Technology Alliance for Global Sustainability)  under one umbrella to crack this challenge- how to do national wealth accounting.   The team collected extensive data and devised a method to calculate  national wealth wherein natural wealth is a non-negotiabel term. The details of this exercise are contained in  the Inclusive Wealth Report 2012.  The report recognized three components  of the National wealth  as follows: 

Wealth =  Human Capital(HC)+ Produced Capital(PC)+ Natural Capital (NC)

While this empirical formula might seem naive it incorporates several layers of complexity behind the facade.  HC is computed taking into account education, skill-set, health etc.Computing  PC will be the easiest since it has a direct bearing on the GDP and  cover all products (industrial + agricultural, roads,buildings etc.)   NC, Natural wealth itself is viewed from three different angles: the intrinsic value, use value and optional value and assessed among other things in terms of irreversible uses and substitution possibilities and renewable resources.  Inclusive Wealth index (IWI) evaluated based on these premises falls below the GDP and HDI. IWR 2012 was also  the first step towards sensitizing governments  for the need for a cautious balance between growth rate and ecological integrity. 

IWR 2014 report is significant  is a jump forward from the 2012 report for several reasons. For example while  The 2012 reported covered 20 countries, the present report covers 140 countries. Its focus is the human capital; a    great national asset which could very easily turn into a liability.   The Human capital computation with   educational and health components as key changemakers  has received stringent scrutiny.  As Anantha Duraiappahin  states in the Preface of IWR 2014 -

 "We hope that policy-makers at the international, national, and state level will see the IWR 2014 as a useful tool, and as encouragement to take the steps necessary to close gaps in data and to utilize the inclusive wealth accounts presented in the report as guidance "  

Here is a snippet from the voluminous data in the report.  Since BRICS countries  will have a strong influence on the fate of  the world in years to come-by, I have just picked the details of the  BRICS group and thrown in western Europe and the USA and world data for comparison.   This for the 20 year period 1990-2010.     

While the results could be viewed through several filters ( single  or in combination), what stands out remarkable is way forward to  reach  a win-win situation. 
   
Reference : 

1.UNU-IHDP and UNEP (2014). Inclusive Wealth Report 2014. Measuring progress toward sustainability. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
2..UNU-IHDP and UNEP (2012). Inclusive Wealth Report 2014. Measuring progress toward sustainability. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press